TCS dog crate test: Some models fall apart!
Over half a million dogs are kept in Switzerland. If you are traveling with your four-legged friends in the car, they should be kept in a dog crate for their own protection and that of the other passengers. As the TCS test shows, there are a few things to bear in mind here.
Even for the short distance to the forest walk or to the vet, the safety of your dog should be a priority when traveling by car. The four-legged friend should always be transported safely and not just on longer journeys. After all, a safe dog crate not only protects the animal, but also the vehicle occupants. But which of the wide range on offer is really safe?
The TCS therefore tested nine dog crates in different price categories, ranging from 95 to 900 francs. The criteria evaluated were safety, suitability for the dog, handling, cleaning and care. The tests included dynamic driving maneuvers and crash tests with a dog dummy. While some boxes proved to be highly stable in the crash test, other models shattered or even disintegrated into their individual parts. Particularly inexpensive boxes performed significantly worse. There were major differences in terms of comfort and suitability for dogs. While stable materials and emergency exits stood out positively, some models lacked non-slip mats or safe entrances.
Clear differences in crash safety
The Cadoca dog transport box L and the Roony dog transport box M are rated "conditionally recommended", as they clearly fail to meet the minimum safety requirements. At CHF 95, the size L dog transport box from Cadoca is the cheapest box in the test, and the quality and stability of the materials match the price. In the crash test, the rear wall splintered, posing a clear risk of injury. The Roony product's sharp edges, poor workmanship and lack of instructions for fitting in the vehicle are clear safety deficiencies. During the crash test, the rear panel shatters and the remaining tubes and connections almost disintegrate into their individual parts. The dog literally "flies" out of the box.
The Freezack aluminum dog box Rocky and the Trixie transport box M are practical to use, but also have weaknesses in the crash test. Nevertheless, they can still be classified as "recommendable". The more expensive models performed significantly better and are therefore "highly recommended". The Thule Allax M impressed with its adjustment options and emergency exit, but still showed some weaknesses when it came to cleaning and maintenance. The Tavo Crispin M scored as the lightest box in the test and was easy to attach with Isofix. The top models include the 4Pets Pro 1 and the two products from Schmidt Fahrzeugbau: the Universal Premium self-assembly box and the Premium Kennel. These boxes showed hardly any deformation in the crash test, have a high-quality finish, offer the dog a secure hold and therefore scored "excellent".
Do not sacrifice safety for price
The test makes it clear that those who save money when buying a dog crate often compromise on safety - exactly where they should do so the least. The TCS recommends paying attention to tested stability, a perfect fit and professional installation. Boxes for the rear seat bench can be an equivalent alternative to the trunk. Accessories such as floor mats, locks or fastening elements not only increase comfort, but also safety.
The results of the TCS dog crate test at a glance
